Reliability Hotwire, a Reliasoft monthly eMagazine for reliability professionals, published two papers recently entitled: “Taguchi Robust Design for Product Improvement” http://www.weibull.com/hotwire/issue122/index.htm , and Taguchi Robust Design for Product Improvement: Part II http://www.weibull.com/hotwire/issue123/index.htm I read the first paper in issue 122 (post-publication) and found many issues and discrepancies. I had worked with Dr. Taguchi directly for approximately 10 years while I managed the Xerox Robust Engineering Center. I had numerous other interactions through Taguchi’s affiliation with American Supplier Institute in Detroit . I responded to Reliasoft and the author of the paper regarding the first publication, but no modifications were made . I was …